S26 — 5,200-cell review
Specification audit
52 families × 10 requirements × 10 lenses = 5,200 cells from 520 underlying requirements. Scores are editorial document judgments for the v2 brief + navigable prototype—not live test results. Implementation status remains NOT TESTED until executed.
Overall family mean (editorial): 2.41 / 4
Formula
parameter_score = min(requirement_specificity, family_lens_rating)
Scale 0–4: absent · broad intention · partial · actionable with dependency · explicit/bounded/traceable.
Files
docs/audit/civendale-5200-specification-audit.csvdocs/audit/civendale-520-requirements.jsondocs/audit/family-score-summary.jsondocs/audit/REQUIREMENTS_TEXT.md— CVD ID texts
Family means
| Family | Mean | Status |
|---|---|---|
| F01 · Brand proposition and naming | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F02 · Logo and brand applications | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F03 · Color and semantic tokens | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F04 · Typography grid and spacing | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F05 · Homepage hero and instant clarity | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F06 · Interactive community-space preview | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F07 · Public narrative and authentic proof | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F08 · Four audience entry experiences | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F09 · Navigation search and footer | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F10 · Category and restroom experience | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F11 · Product detail and evidence | 2.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F12 · Compare shortlist and saved intent | 2.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F13 · Expert and service directory | 1.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F14 · Studio brief and human assistance | 2.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F15 · Project Room collaboration | 2.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F16 · Exchange opportunity experience | 1.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F17 · Academy learning and discussion | 2.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F18 · Care and lifecycle experience | 1.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F19 · Manufacturer dashboard | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F20 · Government dashboard | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F21 · Professional firm dashboard | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F22 · Representative dashboard | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F23 · User organization switch and team | 2.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F24 · Responsive mobile and device usability | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F25 · Accessibility and inclusive authentication | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F26 · Motion media and performance | 1.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F27 · State design and microcopy | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F28 · Trust content and administered presentation | 2.60 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F29 · Universal registration entry and minimal fields | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F30 · Identity reuse verification and recovery | 1.60 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F31 · Manufacturer registration | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F32 · Government registration | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F33 · Professional Service Firm registration | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F34 · Rep registration and appointment claims | 3.60 | PROTOTYPE_IMPLEMENTED |
| F35 · Resumption duplication and invitations | 2.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F36 · Activation and registration analytics | 1.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F37 · Civendale operator Subscription ID | 2.60 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F38 · Participant organization Worlds | 2.60 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F39 · UID EID Application Sphere and Tab mapping | 1.60 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F40 · Core record and API discovery map | 2.60 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F41 · Provisioning states and idempotency | 2.60 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F42 · Core MySQL and PostgreSQL projections | 1.60 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F43 · Authorization sharing and tenant isolation | 1.60 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F44 · Security error handling and observability | 1.60 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F45 · Commercial appointments and territory rights | 1.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F46 · Product sourcing and technical provenance | 1.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F47 · Procurement and professional review boundaries | 2.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F48 · Verification administration and support operations | 2.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F49 · Retention exit and public records | 1.30 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F50 · AI and approved integrations | 1.30 | BLOCKED_CONTRACT |
| F51 · Pilot economics and verified coverage | 1.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |
| F52 · Deliverables evidence and release gates | 2.30 | PROTOTYPE_PARTIAL |